Sports

St Kilda denied goal in controversial ruling as magnificent Melbourne hammer them in the first half

Ripped off or a ‘rookie error’? St Kilda denied a goal in controversial ruling as magnificent Melbourne hammer them in the first half on their option to fifteenth win in a row

  • Harrison Petty dominated to have touched Tim Membrey kick for goal in first interval 
  • Score review was inconclusive and goal umpire’s ruling stood for a behind 
  • Fans weren’t joyful and blamed Petty for leaping off the mark 

St Kilda had been all the time more likely to want all the assist they might get to beat the red-hot Demons on Sunday – however they ended up copping a controversial name that denied them a desperately wanted goal as an alternative.

With Melbourne main 4.2 (26) to 0.2 (2) in the first quarter, Saints centre half ahead Tim Membrey marked barely to the left of goal about 15 metres out and kicked true – just for the goal ump to name it touched.

A rating review adopted and was inconclusive, resulting in an umpire’s name – and the behind stood.

Tim Membrey was blamed for making a 'rookie error' that resulted in Harrison Petty getting a fingertip to the ball and denying St Kilda a crucial goal

Tim Membrey was blamed for making a ‘rookie error’ that resulted in Harrison Petty getting a fingertip to the ball and denying St Kilda a vital goal

But many Saints fans blew up at the umpire who called it (pictured) and said the Demons defender had broken the stand rule by jumping off the mark

But many Saints followers blew up at the umpire who known as it (pictured) and stated the Demons defender had damaged the stand rule by leaping off the mark

Saints followers howled in protest at the floor and on-line, however former Collingwood coach Nathan Buckley laid the blame squarely at Membrey’s ft.

‘Rookie error involves thoughts. Tim Membrey is not a rookie, however typically while you’re underneath stress the easy issues aren’t finished effectively,’ Buckley stated.

‘He simply did not give himself sufficient area.’

However, followers had been fast to launch into the man on the mark, Harrison Petty, and declare he was at fault for breaking the stand rule.

‘Standing on the mark rule simply disappeared, did not know you may soar ahead,’ wrote Nick Lambden-Grant.

Demons veteran Angus Brayshaw celebrates after kicking a stunner from about 50 metres out on a tight angle as Melbourne gave the Saints a football lesson early on

Demons veteran Angus Brayshaw celebrates after kicking a stunner from about 50 metres out on a good angle as Melbourne gave the Saints a soccer lesson early on

Tom McDonald (right) chest bumps Tom Sparrow after kicking a sausage roll in the second quarter as the Dees piled on the misery

Tom McDonald (proper) chest bumps Tom Sparrow after kicking a sausage roll in the second quarter as the Dees piled on the distress

‘What about the stand rule?’ requested Michael White.

‘Fifty metre penalty,’ tweeted Leon Tracy.

The first half obtained far worse from there for St Kilda, with the Demons piling on 4 unanswered targets early in the second time period, main 52-9 at one level earlier than the Saints pulled them again to make it 9.3 (57) to three.4 (22) at the fundamental break.

Coach Brett Ratten would possibly need to document his halftime speak and use it once more this year as his costs restricted the Dees to 1 goal in the third quarter whereas kicking two themselves to scale back the hole to twenty-eight factors going into the final interval.

Kysaiah Pickett starred early for Melbourne, Ben Brown had three targets by three-quarter time and Clayton Oliver led all gamers with 28 possessions.

Advertisement

Back to top button